Veterinary Behaviorist vs. Dog Trainer
- Everwell Pets
- Aug 11
- 5 min read
Why It's Important To Understand The Difference
A dog trainer is like a psychologist. They focus on your dog’s thoughts, patterns, and behaviors. They use reward systems, behavior shaping, and training exercises. They help build confidence, reduce stress, and create structure.
A veterinary behaviorist, by contrast, is like a psychiatrist. They’ve gone through veterinary school, then completed a 2–4 year residency in animal behavior. They understand the interplay between medical conditions and behavior and are equipped to diagnose and prescribe. But they don’t usually hold training sessions or help you teach a solid “heel” or “stay.” Their work is more internal—biochemical, neurochemical, and diagnostic in nature.
Both roles can be helpful—but they’re not the same. And understanding that difference can save you time, money, and heartache.
The History of the profession of Veterinary Behaviorist
Discussions around veterinary behavioral medicine began gaining traction in the early 1980s, as professionals across multiple disciplines started exploring the deeper “why” behind animal behavior, studying of how animals think, feel, and act—both instinctively and through learned experiences.
It blends neuroscience, psychology, ethology (the observation of animals in natural environments), and even veterinary medicine to better understand why dogs bark, bite, tremble, freeze, jump, chew your furniture, or gently nudge your hand when you’re sad.
In the pet world, this study helps us make sense of our dogs’ quirks and cues and guides trainers and professionals in developing thoughtful, evidence-based ways to support or redirect behavior.
By the early 80s, pioneers in this field were already changing the game. Marian Breland Bailey—one of B.F. Skinner’s students—was applying operant conditioning principles to real-world animal training, proving that kindness and reinforcement worked far better than punishment.
Alongside her husband, Bob Bailey, they developed clicker training systems used with everything from dolphins to chickens, and laid the foundation for modern positive-reinforcement dog training [1].
Meanwhile, ethologists like Eckhard Hess were challenging rigid behaviorist thinking by studying imprinting and emotional responses in animals, making the case for naturalistic observation and evolutionary context [2].
Around the same time, psychologist James Serpell was diving deep into the human–animal bond, ethics, and welfare, ultimately developing one of the first large-scale behavioral assessments for dogs [3].
In the veterinary world, Dr. R.K. Anderson emerged as a revolutionary figure—he helped usher in a shift away from punitive training and toward motivational behavior approaches, and even invented the Gentle Leader head collar to help improve the human-dog relationship [4].
With such diverse voices—from psychology and ethology to veterinary medicine—all converging on a shared goal of improving animal welfare through science, it was only a matter of time before the field formalized.
In 1993, the American Veterinary Medical Association granted provisional recognition to the American College of Veterinary Behaviorists (ACVB) [5], and veterinary behavior medicine became a true specialty.
Why The Title of Animal Behaviorist Is A Misleading Problem
Let’s pause for a moment to acknowledge something that trips up a lot of pet parents: the title “veterinary behaviorist” sounds like someone who helps with training, doesn’t it? I mean—behaviorist. It’s technically accurate, but practically misleading.
When a client calls to schedule with a behaviorist, they often expect a professional who will help their dog learn not to lunge at the mail carrier or freak out when left alone. But what they get is a licensed veterinarian with advanced credentials in behavior medicine—someone who diagnoses and prescribes. Behavior modification plans? Not usually. Hands-on help with leash reactivity or crate training? Also no. That’s the trainer’s lane, not the behaviorist’s.
Unfortunately, what I often see in clinical practice is this: the primary veterinarian, feeling out of their depth with a difficult behavioral case, refers the client straight to the veterinary behaviorist.
In doing so, they skip over all the incredibly effective tools and steps that could have helped first—things like working with a skilled trainer, changing the dog’s food to reduce inflammation (yes, raw feeding can make a huge difference), incorporating herbs from Traditional Chinese Medicine, or even trying CBD.
I’ve seen these options work better than prescription drugs in many cases—especially when used in combination and customized to the individual dog. But those paths often get skipped, simply because the word "behaviorist" suggests a more complete solution than it typically delivers.
Costs Of A First-time Animal Behavorist Visit
If you're considering whether a veterinary behaviorist is the right fit for your pup, cost is a factor worth considering. At Tufts University, for example, an initial 90-minute behavior consult is $585 [6]. Other board-certified veterinary behaviorists across the U.S. commonly charge between $400–600 for a first appointment, with follow-ups ranging around $150–250 depending on the complexity of the case [7]. These visits usually include an extensive intake, a behavioral diagnosis (which may involve ruling out medical causes), and often the prescription of medication.
And yes, you read that right—prescription medications. Veterinary behaviorists can prescribe drugs like fluoxetine (generic Prozac), sertraline (Zoloft), trazodone, and others to manage anxiety, reactivity, aggression, compulsive behaviors, and phobias.
While some do offer training advice or refer you to a trainer, their main tool is the medical model.
(Don’t miss next week’s follow-up blog, where we’ll take a deeper dive into the wide range of psychoactive drugs being used with pets today—and what you absolutely should know before agreeing to them.)
Final Thoughts
If you’re dealing with an unruly adolescent pup or a new rescue adjusting to home life, a professional dog trainer can work wonders. Trainers help build structure, boundaries, and communication between you and your dog—often bridging the gap between chaos and calm.
But if you’re facing deeper issues like severe anxiety, persistent aggression, compulsive behaviors, or irrational fears that don’t respond to training, it may be time to bring in the big guns: a veterinary behaviorist.
By understanding who does what—and when to call whom—you empower yourself to make better choices for your dog’s emotional and behavioral well-being. Just like humans, our pets sometimes need therapy, sometimes need training, and sometimes need medical help. Knowing where each specialty fits can help you get the right support at the right time.
Curious which one your dog might need? Book a consult with Dr. Andi for an in-depth, personalized analysis !
Book a Pet Wellness Coaching Session With Dr. Andi Today!
Don't miss out on natural pet health and wellness tips and stay ahead of seasonal news by subscribing to our free weekly newsletter, The Everwell Digest, where we deliver all the tasty tid-bits right to your bowl!
Citations